| Name | Date elected | Notes |
|---|
| C.P. Grenfell | 3rd Aug. 1846 (At the first meeting) | |
| Rowland Hill | " " | |
| Capt. B.M. Kelly, R.N. | " " | |
| E. Wigan | " " | |
| Leo Schuster | " " | |
| Capt. The Hon G.F. Hotham, R.N | " " | |
| C.S. Crowley | " " | |
| W.A. Wilkinson | " " | |
| J. Lawrie | " " | |
| J. Thompson | " " | |
| E. Watson | " " | |
| H. de Castro | " " | |
| E. Crowley | " " | |
| B. Baines | " " | |
| J.M. Parsons | " " | |
| J. Whiskin | " " | |
| J. Nix | 7th Dec. 1846 | |
| S. Laing | 24th July 1848, retired 1851, re-elected 2nd July 1867 | Born 1812, died 1897. |
| J. Whishaw | 7th Aug. 1848 | |
| W. Cash | 7th Aug. 1848 | |
| B. Hankey | 17th Dec. 1849 | |
| C. Lushington, M.P. | 19th Dec. 1849 | |
| Capt. J.M. Laws, R.N. | 8th Mar. 1855 | |
| J. Scott | 17th July 1855 | |
| T.W Henderson | 16th Jan. 1856 | |
| W. Coningham, M.P. | 9th Aug. 1864 | |
| P.N. Lawrie | 10th Mar. 1859 | |
| Col. W.B. Barttelot, M.P. | 9th Aug. 1864 | |
| Sir F.L. Arthur, Bart. | 4th July 1865 | |
| C. Child | 6th Nov. 1865 | |
| C.E. Stewart | 26th Feb. 1867 | |
| Sir C.R.M. Jackson | 25th June 1867 | |
| R.L. Lopes | 25th June 1867 | |
| J. Levy | 25th June 1867 | |
| C.B. Cardew | 25th June 1867 | |
| Hon. T.F. Fremantle | 15th Jan. 1868 | Later Lord Cottesloe |
| A.J. Otway, M.P. (Retired) | 15th Jan. 1868 | |
| Sir Arthur Otway | Re-elected 25th Jan. 1868 | |
| G.E. Wythes | 15th Jan. 1868 | |
| Lord Geo. Gordon Lennox, M.P. | 11th Mar. 1868 | |
| Lord Alex. Gordon Lennox | 7th Dec. 1870 | |
| Sir P. Rose, Bart. | 17th Mar. 1875 | |
| J.P. Bickersteth | 16th May 1883 | |
| R. Jacomb Hood | 7th Mar. 1883 | |
| Sir Julian Goldsmid, Bart., M.P. | 30th Sep. 1891 | |
| Ald. Sir F.W. Truscott | 27th Jan. 1892 | |
| C.C. Macrae | 1st Nov. 1893 | |
| Lord Hy. Nevill | 25th July 1894 | |
| Viscount Duncannon | 20th Mar. 1895 | Later Earl of Bessborough |
| G.W.E. Loder, M.P. | 22nd Jan. 1896 | |
| Baron F. de Rothschild | 24th June 1898 | |
| Sir Allen Sarle | 26th Jan. 1898 | |
| Rear-Admiral Hon. T.S. Brand | 29th May 1900 | |
| Major P. Cardew, R.E. | 29th Jan. 1902 | |
| W. Milburn | 29th Jan. 1902 | |
| Sir S. Walpole, K.C.B. | 29th Jan. 1902 | |
| Sir C.W. Fielding | 31st July 1907 | |
| C.J. Lucas | 31st July 1907 | |
| F. Freeman Thomas | 31st July 1907 | Later Lord Willingdon |
| Sir P.F. Rose, Bart. | 17th June 1908 | |
| J.F.S. Gooday | 25th May 1910 | |
| Lord Edmund Talbot, M.P. | 2nd Apr. 1913 | Later Viscount Fitzalan |
| Sir R. Turnbull, M.V.O. | 10th Feb. 1915 | |
| Sir C.L. Morgan, C.B.E. | 21st Feb. 1917 | |
| F.D. Docker, C.B. | 19th Jan. 1921 | |